Subscribe to TrevorHoppe.com





Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons License


September 15, 2009

Is Promoting Male Circumcision as Prevention Ethical?
By Trevor

circumcision-05.jpg

The UNAIDS has just released a report (story | report) saying that "between five and fifteen men will need to be circumcised to prevent one HIV infection in the ten following years, at a cost of between $150 and $900 per infection prevented." Their conclusion: circumcision is a "cost-effective" intervention strategy for HIV prevention. In this report, there is no consideration for whether this procedure is ethical. Nor is there any consideration of what kinds of cultural meanings might be attached to the foreskin in communities they're ready to scalpel -- or how a mass program to remove their foreskins might be interpreted and expressed culturally.

I like to use the example that reader Thomas Kraemer provided a few weeks back in the comments: We could cure breast cancer tomorrow if we could just institutionalize double mastectomies for young girls. Or as my professor cynically joked the other day, "Why stop at the tip of the penis? If we could remove the whole shebang we could rid society of any number of not just medical, but social ills as well!" Oh, sure, some folks out there will resent the comparisons. "The breast is more important than the foreskin!" To this response, I have just one question: "Says who?"

I think we desperately need to be mobilizing against this movement towards circumcision. It's wrong-headed, poorly thought-through, and is really aimed at circumscribing any need for creative prevention approaches by creating a biomedical intervention. The crisis is clear: Prevention specialists -- trained in the too-often culturally incompetent fields of health and biomedicine -- are just downright flummoxed by the inability of their interventions to stem the rise in new infections. If you've ever worked in the field, you've undoubtedly seen their red-faced angst before: "Why won't these people just use condoms, goddammit?" Nevermind the structural constraints of poverty and gender. Nevermind the meanings implicitly and inadvertently attached to condoms by Western medicine (e.g. distrust, fear, etc.).

Thus, in an era when classical prevention strategies are failing globally, old-school prevention types have opted to search for a biomedical intervention that would avoid any need for dealing with the messy realm of the social. "If we can just chop something off, then we won't have to deal with compliance!" Ta-dah! The magical solution! Obviously, this logic is outrageously problematic. It presumes that circumcision will not be rife with cultural meanings and dilemmas, and it also presumes a hostile population that is "non-compliant." It never allows for the consideration that perhaps it is prevention that is the problem -- not the communities it seeks to change.

I am amazed by the number of studies in epidemiology -- the sheer mass of publications -- that continue to rely on behavioral survey instruments that unreflexively presume a set of concerns worth asking about that stem from an understanding of the epidemic in which it is people's behaviors that fuels the HIV/AIDS epidemic. This is downright shameful given the massive amounts of data that demonstrate how obviously correlated new infections are with social-structural factors like race, class, gender, and sexuality. It's like trying to telling people in Detroit to eat better when there is no grocery store -- not a single one -- within city limits.

It's past the point of naivety -- since the amount of data demonstrating the epidemic's social-structural roots is so compelling. It amounts to a kind of willful ignorance to continue trying what you know will likely fail because it is easily funded and requires little critical thought. It's easy. It's lazy. It would all be a bit humorous if it wasn't resulting in a body of prevention literature that does very little to actually work towards meaningful prevention. People are dying. Scientists are laughing their way to the CDC-NIH bank.

Removing foreskin in the name of health promotion is unconscionable. It amounts to a kind of cultural imperialism that will undoubtedly stir up backlash against Western Public Health. The idea is not seen as radical because we in the US already practice it so commonly. But believe me: If circumcision was virtually unknown in the United States as it is in other areas around the Globe, we would not be having this debate. But because it is such an institution here, the idea of promoting it elsewhere seems totally sensible. It's the worst kind of ethnocentrism, and it needs to stop.

PERMALINK | Posted at 9:48 AM | Post a Comment (11)

11 Comments

Trevor -

Your comments regarding the ethical and cultural considerations of voluntary male circumcision are well-intended. However, the blanket assumption that this practice a) does not have a historical basis in Africa and b) is not wanted by men in Africa is not evidence-based.

Consider the following report from the health ministry of Kenya: http://www.malecircumcision.org/programs/documents/KenyaMCguidance.pdf
This report details the cultural history of male circumcision as an initiation rite in some traditional Kenyan cultures. Specifically, over 90 percent of men are already circumcised in four provinces, and 84 percent of men nationwide are already circumcised. While this behavior is not generalizable to all of sub-Saharan Africa, it violates the assumption that male circumcision is a Western practice that is being unduly imposed upon African peoples.
Furthermore, the report released by UNAIDS does not recommend mandating male circumcision. Instead it advocates for an increase in the availability of voluntary male circumcision services in sub-Saharan Africa, particularly where there is strong demand for services. UNAIDS and the WHO already have strong guidelines with adequate human rights protections for the implementation of voluntary male circumcision:
http://tinyurl.com/ndd6cc
http://tinyurl.com/no7klg
These guidelines were created in response to high demand for male circumcision by men who wanted to reduce their risk for HIV. This demand, particularly in South Africa (http://allafrica.com/stories/200907220206.html) and Kenya (http://www.plusnews.org/Report.aspx?ReportId=85082), has overwhelmed the available services. Indeed, many providers are worried that if men are circumcised, they will believe that this protects them from HIV and will reduce their condom use. Similarly, demand among MSM for circumcision is also problematic, as it is not effective in reducing HIV infection from anal sex. These are two strong arguments against promoting voluntary male circumcision, and they must be weighed against the considerable benefits population-wide of increased male circumcision.

I do not disagree with your hesitation about recommending a permanent surgical procedure to reduce HIV infection. I do, however, take issue with the idea that it is entirely ethnocentric and unwanted by men in sub-Saharan Africa. My work in HIV prevention with MSM in Burundi and the general population in other countries in the Great Lakes region of central Africa has demonstrated to me that individuals are willing to go to extreme lengths to protect themselves from HIV while still not using condoms. Offering a voluntary surgical method with some efficacy as an option to reduce HIV infection is one tool that both empowers men to make their own decisions about how to protect themselves from HIV and may reduce the prevalence of some non-prophylactic prevention methods that may increase HIV infection (washing the penis with bleach, among others). A naive view of voluntary male circumcision as Western imperialism does little to advance the cause of HIV prevention.

Author Profile Page sdickson13 User Profile | September 15, 2009 11:00 AM

Trevor,

It is COMPLETELY unethical. I cannot agree with your more on what you have just posted. Thank you for speaking out, and doing it so well. What's going on now with this circumcision hysteria is barbaric. Condoms and testing are the only HIV prevention strategies that are known to work. If people aren't using them, we need to find out why and address it.

Author Profile Page Caroline User Profile | September 16, 2009 2:39 AM

Also, you will probably like this blog

circumcisionandhiv.com

and this Youtube channel

http://www.youtube.com/user/Bonobo3D

Of the movies, Dr. Dean Edell is particularly vocal in explaining all the flawed logic with the HIV studies.

Author Profile Page Caroline User Profile | September 16, 2009 2:50 AM

What's more of a problem is that it simply won't work. There are six African countries where men are more likely to be HIV+ if they've been circumcised: Cameroon, Ghana, Lesotho, Malawi, Rwanda, and Swaziland. Eg in Malawi, the HIV rate is 13.2% among circumcised men, but only 9.5% among intact men. In Rwanda, the HIV rate is 3.5% among circumcised men, but only 2.1% among intact men. If circumcision really worked against AIDS, this just wouldn't happen. We now have people calling circumcision a "vaccine" or "invisible condom", and viewing circumcision as an alternative to condoms.

The one study into male-to-female transmission showed a 50% higher rate in the group where the men had been circumcised btw.

ABC (Abstinence, Being faithful, Condoms) is the way forward. Promoting genital surgery will cost African lives, not save them.

Author Profile Page Mark Lyndon User Profile | September 16, 2009 8:02 AM

Well said, Trevor. It amazes me that the African trials are even seen as legitimate within the medical community, when they failed to control for the HIV status of the men's partners before the study began. That's just shoddy science.

And then there's the pesky problem of empirical evidence, which shows that majority-circumcised USA has higher per-capita rates of just about every STD (including HIV) than non-circumcising Europe and Japan. If male circumcision were really as effective as its proponents claim, we would not see this in real-world situations.

We cannot apply the results of an odd (and many would say faulty) study in Africa to the industrialized west. There are far too many cultural, educational and hygiene factors to consider -- beyond the fact that there's a huge difference between a consenting adult participating in a study and a non-consenting minor being welcomed to the world by a mutilating surgery.

Author Profile Page https://www.google.com/accounts/o8/id?id=AItOawnuivSOKhpRnieODKrWhAd-Vrna1ySaZVM User Profile | September 16, 2009 8:33 AM


About Us
Trevorade is a community of people just like you who spend their days thinking about sex, gay men's health, and HIV/AIDS. Welcome!

We Need Your Support
We're supported almost exclusively by donations from generous souls like yourself. So please, if you enjoy the content here, shell out a few gay dollars to help us cover our hosting bills.










Clips N' Chips
Liberal-Minded. Antillean-American. Queer. Non-PC Feminist.
Joe. My. God.
Gay Culture, Short Stories, & More! NY-Based.
Kaleidoscope
 Fellow Ann Arborite and Gay Blogger. Sexuality & Human Rights focus.
Knucklecrack
Gay Activist Eric Levin's Fabulous NY-Based Blog.
Lifelube
Gay, Sexy, Healthy - Just Like You!
Pam's House Blend
She's a fabulous North Carolinian blogging about politics, LGBT and women's rights, the influence of the far Right, and race relations. What more can I say?


19th Century
ABC
abortion
abstinence
academia
Acapulco
ACLU
ACT UP
activism
Adam Lambert
Adam4Adam
Adrienne Rich
advertising
aesthetics
Africa
age of consent
AIDS in Culture
AIDS Inc
airlines
Alan Cumming
Alice Newton
Alix Olsen
Allan Berube
Amanda Blank
Amazon.com
Amber Hollibaugh
America's Next Top Model
American Idol
American Sexuality Magazine
Americans
anal queefing
anal sex
Ancient History
Anderson Cooper
Andre Cavalcante
Andrew Sullivan
Ann Arbor
Antiretrovirals
Apple
archival research
Argentina
Armed Forces
Art
art fair
astrology
atlanta
Australia
AutBar
bacon
Badlands
banned
bareback
barebacking
Barry Adams
bathhouse
Batman
Bay Area Reporter
BBC
Bea Arthur
bears
Berkeley
Bette Midler
Better World Advertising
Betty White
Beyonce
Beyond Masculinity
bi-curious
bigotry
bikes accidents
Bill Clinton
Bill Frist
Black gay men
Blackness
blogging
blow job
body image
Boston
Bottom identity
bougie white people
Brazil
Brent Corrigan
Britney Spears
Broadway
Brokeback Mountain
Bruce LaBruce
bullying
Bush Administration
Butt Magazine
California
call for papers
Calpernia Addams
Cameron Diaz
Camille Paglia
camp
campaign financing
Canada
cancer
capital punishment
capitalism
Carribean
Castro
Catholic Church
Cathy Cohen
Cazwell
CDC
Celine Dion
censorship
charity
Charlize Theron
Charlotte
Che Guevara
Cher
Chicago
China
chlamydia
Chris Bartlett
Christina Aguilera
Christina Applegate
Christopher Columbus
Chronicle of Higher Education
CIA
circuit boys
circumcision
civil rights
class politics
clubbing
CNN
cocaine
coming out
commodification
community
Community HIV/AIDS Mobilization Project
condoms
Congress
Connecticut
conservatives
cooking
copyright laws
Cornell
corporate welfare
corruption
Cortland Review
counterpublic health
country music
Craigslist
Creating Change
criminal justice
cruise ship
crystal methamphetamine
CTOPS
Cuba
cultural studies
D&X Abortions
daddies
Daily Beast
DailyKos
Dan Savage
Daniel Reeders
Danny DeVito
David Halperin
David Kaufman
David Letterman
David Malebranche
democrats
Denmark
Desperate Housewives
Destiny's Child
Detroit
Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe
Dick Cheney
dieting
disclosure
disco
discrimination
disidentification
Disney
divas
DOMA
douche bags
douching
drag queens
drugs
DSM
eagle
Ebay
Economics
economy
Edmund White
elderly
elections
Elizabeth Pisani
Ellen DeGeneres
England
epidemiology
epistemology
Eric Leven
Eric Rofes
español
Ethan Suniewick
Ethel Merman
ethics
ethnocentrism
European Union
Eurovision
Evan Wolfson
exams
Facebook
facial
family
Family Guy
fascism
Fashion
Father's Day
fausto fernos
FDA
feastoffun
FEMA
femininity
feminism
Feminist men
Ferndale
Film studies
Fiona Apple
fiscal responsibility
fisting
fitness
Florida
flow
foreclosure
FOX News
Frameline
France
free speech
Frontiers
FTM
Ganymede
Gary Dowsett
gas prices
gay bashing
Gay bitch
Gay City
gay gene
Gay icons
gay male culture
gay marriage
gay men
gay men's health
Gay Men's Health Leadership Academy
Gay Men's Health Summit
Gay Pride
gay sex
gay stuff
Gay.com
gayborhood
Gayle Rubin
geisha
gender identity
genderfuck
genetics
George W Bush
Germany
Gilbert Herdt
Giovanni's Room
GLAAD
GLBT Historical Society
GLBTSA
GLEE
Glenn Beck
GLF
global health
Gold Coast
Golden Girls
Golden Globes
goldstar
Google
graduate school
Grindr
Guillermo del Toro
H1N1
Haiti
hanky code
Harlequin Superromance
harm reduction
Harry Potter
Harvard
Harvey Milk
hate crimes
HBO
health care
Heather Cassils
Helen Goddard
herpes
heteronormativity
heterosexism
high school
higher education
Hillary Clinton
hipsters
HIV
HIV / AIDS
HIV Panic
HIV Prevention
HIV testing
HIV-positive
Hollywood
homofobia
homophobia
Homophobia
hooking up online
hospitals
HPPC
HPV
Human Rights Campaign
Hurricane Katrina
identity politics
Illinois
IML
immigration
India
individualism
Indonesia
inequality
Inga Muscio
insomnia
Institutional Review Board
insurance companies
intergenerational intimacy
International Mr. Leather
Internet
intersex
Iowa
iPhone
Iran
Iraq
Islam
Israel
iTunes
Ivy League
Jackson Bowman
James Baldwin
James Schuyler
Janet Jackson
Japan
Jean Genet
Jim Pickett
Joe Lieberman
John D'Emilio
John McCain
Jon Stewart
journalism
Juanita More
Judith Butler
Julia Serano
juventud
Juventud
k.d. lang
Kane Race
Kansas
Kansas City
Kanye West
Karl Rove
katastrophe
Kathy Griffin
keith green
Kevin Jennings
Kim & Cookie
kitsch
Kylie Minogue
LA Gay & Lesbian Center
Lady Gaga
LAMBDA
Lambda Literary Foundation
lark ballinger
Larry Kramer
Las Vegas
latino
Lauryn Hill
lawyers
leadership
leather
Legends
Les Natali
lesbians
LGBT Cinema
LGBT culture
LGBT history
LGBT politics
LGBT youth
lgbti health summit
LGBTI Health Summit
libertarianism
Lifelube
Lisa Marie Presley
literary
Liza Minelli
LOGO
London
long term nonprogressors
Longtime Companion
Lord of the Rings
Los Angeles
Los Angeles Times
love
lube
Madonna
Magnet SF
Maine
malaria
Malaysia
ManAlive
Mandy Carter
Manhunt
marc felion
Marilyn Monroe
Marion Cotillard
Mark Snyder
Mark Wunderlich
Married Men
Martha Nussbaum
Martin Luther King Jr.
masculinity
Massachusetts
masturbation
Mattachine Society
Matthew Shepard
Medicine
mentorship
Meredith Vieira
methodology
Mexico
Michael Hurley
Michael Jackson
Michael Moore
Michael Petrelis
Michael Scarce
Michael Warner
Michel Foucault
Michelangelo Signorile
Michigan
Michigan Daily
Microsoft
Middle East
Mika
military
Million Dollar Bill
Minnesota
monogamy
moral panics
morality
Mormon Church
Moscow
Movable Type
Movimiento LGBTTT en México
MRSA
MTV
museveni
music
music videos
mythology
nair
NAMBLA
National Gay and Lesbian Task Force
National Sexuality Resource Center
NBC
Necto
needle exchange
Needles Jones
negative men
neo-nazi
neoliberalism
Netherlands
New York City
New York Times
New Zealand
newspapers
Newsweek
NGLTF
Nicole Kidman
No Doubt
North Carolina
Obama
obesity
okcupid
Olympics
Ongina
Oprah
oral sex
orgies
Original Plumbing
Out Magazine
Outfest
Outkast
Palestine
Pamela Conover
Pansy Division
parenting
Paris
Paris Hilton
Pat Califia
Pat Robertson
Patriot Act
Paul Newman
Peaches
Pedophilia
Perez Hilton
perfume
Peru
Peter Tatchell
pharmaceuticals
Philadelphia
Philippines
philosophy
photography
piercings
plagiarism
Planned Parenthood
pleasure
podcasting
poetry
police
police brutality
poppers
pornography
positional identity
Post exposure prophylaxis
post-race
postmodernism
Powell's
Poz Magazine
Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis
PrEP
President Obama
Pride
Princeton
print media
Prison-industrial complex
progressive
Project Runway
Proposition 8
prospect theory
psychology
public health
public sex
Puebla
Puerto Rico
Queen Latifah
Queer as Folk
queer identity
queer politics
queer studies
queer theory
QueerToday.com
Question of the Day
Quotes from People's Profiles
Rachel Maddow
racialized desire
racism
Racism
Radical Faeries
radio
raid
Raleigh
Rape
recording industry
rectal microbicides
refreshing
religion
RENT
Renée Zellweger
reproductive health
Republican Bastards
Republican party
research
retreat
Richard Labonte
rimming
risky business
Rita Hayworth
Road Trip
Robert Novak
Robyn
Roe v. Wade
Rome
Romeo Void
Royal Oak
RuPaul
RussaYog
Russia
russian river
Saint Foucault
Salon.com
Sam Sparro
San Francisco
San Francisco AIDS Foundation
San Francisco State University
Sarah Palin
Sasha Baren Cohen
Saturday Night Live
Scarlet Johansson
School violence
Scissor Sisters
Scooter Libby
Scott's life
Search engines
Seattle
September 11th
seroadaptation
serosorting
Sex and the City
sex education
sex offenders
Sex Panic
sex work
sex-negativity
Sexism
sexology
SexPols
sexual ethics
sexual health
sexual scripting
Sexuality & LGBT Studies
Sexuality & LGBT Studies
SF Weekly
silver foxes
sissyphobia
Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence
size queens
smoking
social justice
social marketing
social networking
social science
socialism
Sociology
Sordid Lives
South Africa
South America
South Park
Spain
spanish
sports
Starbucks
statistics
Steamworks
stem cells
stereotypes
stigma
stock market
Stonewall
stop AIDS
straight people
suburbia
Sue Hyde
superinfection
Supreme Court
Susan Kippax
Susan Stryker
Suzanne Pharr
Switzerland
syphilis
Taiwan
taso
technology
Ted White
Telephone
television
terrorism
Thailand
Thanksgiving
The Advocate
The Anonymous Gay Sex Column
The Bottom Monologues
The Gayest Podcast in Michigan
The L Word
The Netherlands
The Onion
the South
The Today Show
The Vatican
The View from the Bottom
The Village People
threesomes
Time Magazine
Tina Fey
Toe up
Tom DeLay
Tony Valenzuela
tops
Toronto
Transamerican Love Story
transgender
transphobia
tricks
Troy Wood
Tucker Carlson
Twilight Series
twinks
Twitter
uganda
Ugly Betty
UNC Chapel Hill
unemployment
Union Square
United Kingdom
United Nations
Unity Conference
University of Michigan
Urvashi Vaid
Utah
vacation
vaccine
Vagina Monologues
vaginas
Valentine's Day
vampires
Vermont
Veteran's Day
Viagra
Victoria Beckham
Village Voice
voting
Walmart
Washington DC
wax
Wendy Brown
Whitney Houston
Wicked
William Way
Wisconsin
women of color
Women's Studies
World Health Organization
Xtube
yoga
young gay men
youth
Youtube
Zimbabwe
zines
zoology
Émile Durkheim